Candy Carrots & Carrot Patch Cupcakes

If you’re new around here, one thing you should know about Our Best Bites is that we don’t do very many fancy things, but we love to find un-fancy ways to make it look like we do fancy things.  Fake it till you make it?  Perhaps.  Take tiny molded edible objects, for example.  I am 98% certain you will never, ever find us making fondant and crafting tiny caricatures to adorn a cake people are going to tear apart.  But what I can do?  Roll a starburst between my hands and stick some licorice in it.  Boom.  Fancy.  People will instantly think you have mad skillz when you craft things like tiny carrots.  One of our favorite short-cut tricks for things like this is candy.  And I’m not talking bust-out-the-candy-thermometer candy.  I’m talking like, grab-a-pack-of-something-in-the-check-out-lane-at-Walmart candy.

I first made little orange candy carrots years and years  ago, but back then I put little parsley sprigs in the ends for the greens.  They look adorable, but people are always a little iffy about whether they’re supposed to eat them considering it’s candy with herbs sticking out of them.  Then last year when I was making these cute St. Patrick’s Day favors Kate posted, I realized the green Twizzlers would be perfect in place of my parsley.

Ingredients Needed

This is just a preview of ingredients and method, keep scrolling for full printable recipe.

To Make Candy Carrots

  • Orange Starburst candies – You can use any orange colored pliable candy, and if you walk the candy aisle you might find more options than you knew of.  I’m using Starburst here, I’ve also used the orange Tootsie rolls (my WinCo grocery store usually sells them in bulk), and orange Airheads.  Starbursts are a good size because all you need to do is cut one in half and it’s the perfect size for 2 carrots. You can make the Carrots larger or smaller depending on your preferences.
  • Twizzlers Twists Rainbow Candy – This pack of Twizzlers comes with a rainbow of fruity candy. The green ones are perfect to top your carrots.

To Make Carrot Patch Cupcakes

  • Cupcakes – Homemade, from a box, or store bought.
  • Chocolate frosting – Store bought or homemade. We love this Chocolate Frosting!
  • Cookie crumbs – Oreos or chocolate wafers run through the food processor will work great.

How to Make Candy Carrots & Carrot Patch Cupcakes

To Make the Carrots

  1. Each carrot will use up about half a Starburst worth of candy. Just mold it into a soft cone shape, then use a skewer to poke down the top of the carrot and make an opening to insert the greens. I stick the skewer pretty far down and wiggle it around a little bit.
  2. The green Twizzlers are already in little line shapes, so just cut them into small pieces, and take 3 and press them together at one end, and then nestle them in the opening in your carrot.
  3. You can then gently press with a sharp knife to make little lines down the front of the carrots.

To Make Carrot Patch Cupcakes

  1. Frost your cupcakes with chocolate frosting and press into chocolate cookie crumbs.
  2. Nestle a carrot across the top of the cupcake, or poke it right down into it like it’s growing in the dirt. Note that the cupcakes pictures below are mini sized! You may want to use a whole Starburst for each carrot for full-sized cupcakes.
Mini cupcakes frosted with chocolate frosting and dipped in chocolate cookie crumbs, with a candy carrot stuck into it them to look like it's growing out of the dirt.

Candy Carrots and Carrot Patch Cupcakes

These easy little candy carrots are as delicious as they are adorable! They are perfect for adorning carrot cake or Carrot Patch Cupcakes!
Total Time 10 minutes

Ingredients

For the Carrots

  • orange Starbursts or other pliable orange candy such as Tootsie Rolls or Airheads
  • Twizzlers Twists Rainbow Candy you'll only need the green ones

For the Carrot Patch Cupcakes

  • cupcakes home made from a boxed mix, or store bought
  • chocolate frosting
  • chocolate cookie crumbs from Oreos or chocolate wafers

Instructions

To Make the Candy Carrots

  • Each carrot will use up about half a Starburst worth of candy. Just mold it into a soft cone shape, then use a skewer to poke down the top of the carrot and make an opening to insert the greens. I stick the skewer pretty far down and wiggle it around a little bit.
  • The green Twizzlers are already in little line shapes, so just cut them into small pieces, and take 3 and press them together at one end, and then nestle them in the opening in your carrot.
  • You can then gently press with a sharp knife to make little lines down the front of the carrots.

To Make Carrot Patch Cupcakes

  • Frost your cupcakes with chocolate frosting and press into chocolate cookie crumbs.
  • Nestle a carrot across the top of the cupcake, or poke it right down into it like it’s growing in the dirt. Note that the half Starburst size is perfect for mini cupcakes. You may want to use a whole Starburst for each carrot for full-sized cupcakes.

Notes

  • Depending on how fresh your candy is, sometimes they can be a little hard.  If that’s the case, I’ve found that popping them in the microwave for just a few seconds (5 seconds in mine) softens them perfectly. 
  • For the cupcakes, you could use vanilla frosting with graham crackers crumbs, cinnamon and sugar, or coconut flakes tinted green in place of the cookie crumbs.
  • These little candy carrots are a great way to decorate Carrot Cake.
Course: Candy, Crafts, Decorations & Frostings, Desserts
Cuisine: Decorations & Frostings
Keyword: Candy Carrots and Carrot Patch Cupcakes
Did You Make This Recipe?Snap a picture, and hashtag it #ourbestbites. We love to see your creations on our Instagram @ourbestbites!

woman in denim shirt holding a salad bowl
Meet The Author

Sara Wells

Sara Wells co-founded Our Best Bites in 2008. She is the author of three Bestselling Cook Books, Best Bites: 150 Family Favorite RecipesSavoring the Seasons with Our Best Bites, and 400 Calories or Less from Our Best Bites. Sara’s work has been featured in many local and national news outlets and publications such as Parenting MagazineBetter Homes & GardensFine CookingThe Rachel Ray Show and the New York Times.

Read More

Join The Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Questions & Reviews

  1. I made Starburst carrots for my cupcakes last year, and the carrots actually melted into the frosting. 🙁 Anyone else have that problem?

    1. I had the same problem, I made some with starburst and some with orange tootsie rolls. The cupcakes weren’t warm or anything when I stuck the carrots in them. I made the cupcakes the night before and put the candies on in the morning. By the time we were ready to eat them in the afternoon, all the carrots were melty and leaning over like limp noodles. They were still cute and tasted good though.

  2. Wow! These might not be “fancy,” but they are so clever! Can’t wait to use this little trick…