I came across these Silly Cupcakes in the book Hello Cupcake years ago when my boys were little and knew immediately they were right up our alley. I’ve never been that into pranks, so April Fool’s Day was always a day of funny and silliness for us anyway. Using sweet ingredients to turn what looks like dinner into a delicious dessert is the perfect “trick” in my book! From spaghetti and meatballs to mashed potatoes and vegetables, these cute little cupcakes make the sweetest prank!
Ingredients and Supplies Needed
This is just a preview of ingredients and method, keep scrolling for full printable recipe.
- Cupcakes – Make your own Cupcakes or do what I do and pick up some unfrosted cupcakes from your local grocery store or bakery to make things easy!
- Frosting – Same thing. Make your own Buttercream Frosting, or just grab some store-bought frosting.
- Add-ons for desired cupcakes – Ferrero Rocher, jam, and white chocolate or almond bark for spaghetti and meatballs, Starburst and runts for peas and carrots, Starbursts and caramel syrup for mashed potato and gravy, Jelly Bellies and black and clear sprinkles or poppy seeds and sugar for corn, and mini marshmallows for popcorn.
- Piping bag and round tip – For piping spaghetti frosting. You could easily do this with a zip-top bag with the corner cut off as well.
- Disposable muffin tin – Optional, but helps sell the illusion of freshly made savory food!
How to Make Silly Cupcakes
Spaghetti and Meatball Cupcakes
- Using a piping bag with a small round tip. ust by squeezing and holding the bag in one spot, the noodles form by themselves that way. I just held the tip above the cupcake and moved the cupcake around with my hand until the top was covered.
- Our “meatballs” are just Ferrero Rocher candies dunked in a little berry jam. Drizzle a little jam (thinned with hot water if needed) over the frosting noodles and plop a Ferrero Rocher meatball on top.
- If desired, grate a little white chocolate or almond bark to look like parmesan cheese on top!
Peas and Carrots
- Add a thin layer of green frosting to your cupcake.
- Cut orange Starbursts into pieces and shape with your hands into squares to look like carrots. Grab some limes from a Runts mix.
- Arrange your green and orange candies to look like peas and carrots on top of your cupcakes.
Mashed Potatoes
- Frost your cupcakes with white vanilla frosting, leaving a little well at the top.
- Drizzle with caramel syrup to look like gravy and top with a flattened yellow Starburst to look like butter.
Corn on the Cob
- Frost 3 cupcakes with pale yellow frosting. Use Jelly Bellies in white and yellow (buttered popcorn flavor works really well!) to create the corn kernels.
- Top the center with a flattened yellow Starburst or Laffy Taffy for butter.
- Sprinkle with black and clear sprinkles or sugar and poppy seeds to look like salt and pepper.
- Pop some corn cob holders in the ends if desired!
Popcorn
- Make popcorn pieces by cutting a few mini marshmallows into 3 slices with a pair of scissors and then glue another mini marshmallow to the top. You can use the pale yellow ones from a fruit flavored marshmallow mix or white would be cute, too.
- Frost your cupcakes and attach your marshmallow popcorn.
Silly Cupcakes for April Fools
These darling cupcakes look like dinner or veggies, but they're really just the sweetest prank around!
Equipment
- disposable foil cupcake tin optional but adds to the illusion of savory foods
- piping bag with round tip or zip-top bag with a hole cut in the corner
Ingredients
For All
- cupcakes
Spaghetti and Meatballs
- pale yellow frosting
- Ferrero Rocher candies
- berry jam
- white chocolate or almond bark candy coating
Peas and Carrots
- light green frosting
- green limes from Runts candy
- orange Starburst candy
Mashed Potatoes
- white or cream frosting
- caramel sauce
- yellow Starburst or Laffy Taffy
Corn on the Cob
- pale yellow frosting
- yellow and white Jelly Belly jelly beans buttered popcorn ones work well
- black and clear sugar sprinkles or sugar and poppy seeds
Popcorn
- white or cream frosting
- mini marshmallows yellow or white
Instructions
Spaghetti and Meatballs
- Using a piping bag with a small round tip. ust by squeezing and holding the bag in one spot, the noodles form by themselves that way. I just held the tip above the cupcake and moved the cupcake around with my hand until the top was covered.
- Our “meatballs” are just Ferrero Rocher candies dunked in a little berry jam. Drizzle a little jam (thinned with hot water if needed) over the frosting noodles and plop a Ferrero Rocher meatball on top.
- If desired, grate a little white chocolate or almond bark to look like parmesan cheese on top!
Peas and Carrots
- Add a thin layer of green frosting to your cupcake.
- Cut orange Starbursts into pieces and shape with your hands into squares to look like carrots. Grab some limes from a Runts mix.
- Arrange your green and orange candies to look like peas and carrots on top of your cupcakes.
Mashed Potatoes
- Frost your cupcakes with white vanilla frosting, leaving a little well at the top.
- Drizzle with caramel syrup to look like gravy and top with a flattened yellow Starburst to look like butter.
Corn on the Cob
- Frost 3 cupcakes with pale yellow frosting. Use Jelly Bellies in white and yellow (buttered popcorn flavor works really well!) to create the corn kernels.
- Top the center with a flattened yellow Starburst or Laffy Taffy for butter.
- Sprinkle with black and clear sprinkles or sugar and poppy seeds to look like salt and pepper.
- Pop some corn cob holders in the ends if desired!
Popcorn
- Make popcorn pieces by cutting a few mini marshmallows into 3 slices with a pair of scissors and then stick another mini marshmallow to the top with a bit of frosting. You can use the pale yellow ones from a fruit flavored marshmallow mix or white would be cute, too.
- Frost your cupcakes and attach your marshmallow popcorn.
Notes
To make your life easier, pick up some premade, unfrosted cupcakes from your grocery store or local bakery!
Did You Make This Recipe?Snap a picture, and hashtag it #ourbestbites. We love to see your creations on our Instagram @ourbestbites!
Questions & Reviews
Great ideas! My birthday is actually on April Fools Day so I may use some of your fun tricks for a surprise for my kids. Great website and I absolutely love your cookbook!
Those are so awesome! That peas and carrots one is the coolest, I think I might have to try them on Friday.
Absolutely adorable. Love these! 🙂
Clever! Clever!
I love April Fools’ Day! Once we all ate out of weird containers–cool whip bowls, random misc. shaped serving dishes, ate with food preparation utensils. NOthing matched. Fun. Also, I like to make the frosted “cake” made out of meatloaf and then frosted with whipped potatoes tinted some color with cute veggie flowers on top. I will make those meatball cupcakes for sure! Thanks.
Ok, I really love this idea. Now I am slightly obsessed with thinking of other ways to make cupcakes look like other food!
And I LOVE the buttered popcorn jelly bellies! You are not the only one Sara!
Hey I heard you gals are going to be at BYU womens conference this year. Does that mean your cookbooks are going to be sold there as well?
These are TOO CUTE!!
Love them!! The corn ones are the best lol! ~Stay beautiful and blessed!!
Wow! You do incredible work! They are so realistic.
I’ve just gotten into baking cupcakes and am always looking for creative ideas to put in my hat for those times I’m in a fun baking mood. I love the meatball idea. Beautiful work!
Last year my in laws planned a way fun April Fools dinner! They made a menu and everything had a goofy name so you had no idea what you were ordering. You had to place what you wanted as an appetizer, main course, and desert. I ended up getting desert as an appetizer. 🙂 You had to order your plate and fork too… if you didn’t place it first you had to eat the first couple courses with your hands. The only goofy name I can remember was they labeled forks as “Ariels Hairbrush” It was super cute and way fun!